Answering Your Comments #13
Oh. My. Goodness. (This is all you'll get from me about the WCTH S7 finale. ;)
Hello and welcome to another Tuesday! It's comment answering time!
But before we dive into that I would like to take a moment to say thank you! Thank you all so, SO much for all the love, encouragement, and kindness you have continued to give to me! I've been writing this blog for almost a year, and God has so wonderfully blessed me with people like you guys! It's all because of Jesus that I am able to do any of this, and I thank Him for the wonderful people I've gotten to talk with, and how He's blessed this blog! And so I say a big thank you to you wonderful Hearties for taking time out of your day to read this blog, and for wanting to share your thoughts with me. I also say thank you most importantly to my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ, Who not only has given me the ability to write, but Who also has saved me from my sins, and adopted me into His family!
And now onto the replies!
Kelley's Girl
Thank you! So appreciate the time and energy you put into this blog and answering all of the comments. God bless!
My Reply
You're very welcome! Thank you for all your kind words and encouragement! I really appreciate it! God Bless!
Anna
So for the past few episodes I have already guessed that Team Nathan was
the path the show would take - and after this episode I think that got
confirmed even though I am wholeheartedly Team Lucas and I'm already sad
to know it probably won't happen. However, I would be okay with
Elizabeth and Nathan together if we got some build-up to it like you
said, little romantic moments (not just misunderstandings and sad
wistful looks from afar). The ending scene was a step in that direction,
but with only one episode left, it's hard to see why she should choose
Nathan when Lucas has been the one actively courting her all season.
I know people will say "the heart wants what the heart wants, and she wants Nathan!" but I can't ignore all the things Lucas has done to show her how much he cares during the last two seasons. I've also seen people comment that Lucas represents her old life, and him using his money to shower her with gifts and attention - but I don't think that's really true. His conversation with her in Union City about seeing Hope Valley as a good place to settle down and start a family shows that he's not really all about material possessions, and while he likes to give her gifts and take her on a nice date, it doesn't mean they didn't come from the heart. He has gone out of his way several times to do sweet things for her and show her that they not only have common interests, but that he is also willing to be involved in things that she is interested in as well. His actions this episode were misguided when he sent off the chapters to his mother, but that's one small blip in an otherwise smooth courtship so far - and I think it was actually good for them to have this tension because it shows that while he is not perfect, he immediately realized he was in the wrong and came back to apologize.
Which brings me back to Nathan - while I'm glad he and Elizabeth finally had the conversation that was necessary for them to move forward, it also makes me ask why it took him so long to get there. Why was he holding back for so long when Elizabeth gave him so many opportunities to explain to her how he's feeling? Maybe he wanted to do things on his own time and he was still hurt that she went to Union City with Lucas - but he's also an adult and the delay in apologizing to her about Emily and the storm makes me question his maturity and readiness for a relationship with her. He's been acting more like a teenager who didn't get his way at first and just wants to mope in silence. It's a really odd way to act after she essentially told him to just ask her out, and it wasn't until after he had the conversation with Bill that he finally got up the courage to tell her anything - and still didn't ask her out!
I don't want to spoil anything in case someone hasn't seen the previews or sneak peek clips, but I have a feeling she'll make her choice towards Nathan more clear in the finale, but the triangle still won't be completely resolved until next season or possibly the Christmas special, if there is one this year. I just hope whoever she doesn't pick still gets to stay on the show because I like both actors (and I LOVE seeing Chris McNally - since I think she won't pick him I'm worried he'll leave, but maybe Fiona will stay in hope valley and then they could end up together? Anything to keep him on the show!).
I know people will say "the heart wants what the heart wants, and she wants Nathan!" but I can't ignore all the things Lucas has done to show her how much he cares during the last two seasons. I've also seen people comment that Lucas represents her old life, and him using his money to shower her with gifts and attention - but I don't think that's really true. His conversation with her in Union City about seeing Hope Valley as a good place to settle down and start a family shows that he's not really all about material possessions, and while he likes to give her gifts and take her on a nice date, it doesn't mean they didn't come from the heart. He has gone out of his way several times to do sweet things for her and show her that they not only have common interests, but that he is also willing to be involved in things that she is interested in as well. His actions this episode were misguided when he sent off the chapters to his mother, but that's one small blip in an otherwise smooth courtship so far - and I think it was actually good for them to have this tension because it shows that while he is not perfect, he immediately realized he was in the wrong and came back to apologize.
Which brings me back to Nathan - while I'm glad he and Elizabeth finally had the conversation that was necessary for them to move forward, it also makes me ask why it took him so long to get there. Why was he holding back for so long when Elizabeth gave him so many opportunities to explain to her how he's feeling? Maybe he wanted to do things on his own time and he was still hurt that she went to Union City with Lucas - but he's also an adult and the delay in apologizing to her about Emily and the storm makes me question his maturity and readiness for a relationship with her. He's been acting more like a teenager who didn't get his way at first and just wants to mope in silence. It's a really odd way to act after she essentially told him to just ask her out, and it wasn't until after he had the conversation with Bill that he finally got up the courage to tell her anything - and still didn't ask her out!
I don't want to spoil anything in case someone hasn't seen the previews or sneak peek clips, but I have a feeling she'll make her choice towards Nathan more clear in the finale, but the triangle still won't be completely resolved until next season or possibly the Christmas special, if there is one this year. I just hope whoever she doesn't pick still gets to stay on the show because I like both actors (and I LOVE seeing Chris McNally - since I think she won't pick him I'm worried he'll leave, but maybe Fiona will stay in hope valley and then they could end up together? Anything to keep him on the show!).
My Reply
Yes, it also saddens me that after all the rooting and hoping I've done for Lucas, it appears that Elizabeth may not even pick him. Lucas and Elizabeth have a very sweet friendship right now, and despite Lucas giving gifts at times or taking Elizabeth out on a fancy date, them coming from the heart is what really matters. Lucas really has a good and kind heart, and would make for a very new and fresh direction for Elizabeth's story, but I will be honest and admit that Nathan has grown on me, and so hopefully that will lessen the pain should Lucas not be Elizabeth choice. However I wouldn't worry just yet about Lucas leaving the show. A lot of Hearties really like his character and I believe that there are more stories to be told for him. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! God Bless!
Kelley's Girl
Well, you already know how I feel about it, lol. I think my biggest
disappointment was the lack of chemistry I saw with Lucas and E in their
scenes together. I actually felt confused after their first scene about
her book. He sounded a bit arrogant, and I didn't like that side of
him. I sure hope that was a one time thing and the writers aren't
putting a change of character in there. Perhaps they have been reading
too many comments on the FB page where people say he has something to
hide...
Nathan. I have never disliked him. In fact, I like him a lot. My three problems with him and Elizabeth are that 1) they seem to be reincarnating Jack with several of the scenes I have seen, and I don't like that. Make Nathan his own man, not Jack part deux. 2) I really don't feel the chemistry between the two of them. I want to, I just don't. And I think it is because we haven't seen enough cute romantic scenes between them. And 3) it's so predictable. She was with a Mountie in the book. The Mountie dies on the show. Let's put her with another Mountie and continue the story line. yawn..I hope they can change my mind.
I have my suspicions as to what might happen this week, but I will wait until your post next week before posting them. Right now I see exactly what I suspected will happen, Elizabeth with the Mountie in the end. And that probably won't be until next season.
Great blog, as usual! Thank you for what you do!!
Nathan. I have never disliked him. In fact, I like him a lot. My three problems with him and Elizabeth are that 1) they seem to be reincarnating Jack with several of the scenes I have seen, and I don't like that. Make Nathan his own man, not Jack part deux. 2) I really don't feel the chemistry between the two of them. I want to, I just don't. And I think it is because we haven't seen enough cute romantic scenes between them. And 3) it's so predictable. She was with a Mountie in the book. The Mountie dies on the show. Let's put her with another Mountie and continue the story line. yawn..I hope they can change my mind.
I have my suspicions as to what might happen this week, but I will wait until your post next week before posting them. Right now I see exactly what I suspected will happen, Elizabeth with the Mountie in the end. And that probably won't be until next season.
Great blog, as usual! Thank you for what you do!!
My Reply
Yeah, I was not a fan of Lucas in that scene too. It may of had to do with the way Chris said the lines, but yes he just couldn't get it through his head that he had crossed a line. (Until he did, and then fully apologized. Lol!) I also do not hate Nathan either. In fact he's been winning me over more and more, but that hasn't stopped me from rooting for Lucas. You also make good points. While I have felt some chemistry with E and N, a lot of other Hearties haven't, and after watching the finale I'm sure a lot of people are asking, "Why would she want to put herself through loving a Mountie again?" Of course we know what they say about "what the heart wants." But yes, it would in some ways be a repeat of Jack and Elizabeth. It would be more like, "Okay, the stories about a teacher and a Mountie, but we had to make the Mountie die, so we'll bring in a new Mountie and keep the story rolling." I'm not totally against the Mountie storyline, but once again, I'm very actor biased and so that's where most if not all my resistance comes from. If I'm being honest I would like to see Lucas become more down to earth. He did sometimes this season and we got to see him become an official member of the Hope Valley family, but I'd like to see more. I actually kind of think his story could be somewhat like Elizabeth's when she first came to HV. She was more prim and proper, and slowly she became the frontier woman she is today. I'd like to see that happen for Lucas too, as I think it would make his character even better!
In the end, either guy would work for Elizabeth. My problem is, are the writers going to continue to give us Team Lucas fans hope next season for something that will never happen? If Elizabeth is going to pick Lucas than okay, but if not I'd prefer for Elizabeth to pick very early next season so then we can root for Lucas to be with someone new, and not just keep hoping for nothing. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! And thank you very much for the encouragement! You are very welcome for the posts and I'm very glad you enjoy them! God Bless!
In the end, either guy would work for Elizabeth. My problem is, are the writers going to continue to give us Team Lucas fans hope next season for something that will never happen? If Elizabeth is going to pick Lucas than okay, but if not I'd prefer for Elizabeth to pick very early next season so then we can root for Lucas to be with someone new, and not just keep hoping for nothing. Thanks for sharing your thoughts! And thank you very much for the encouragement! You are very welcome for the posts and I'm very glad you enjoy them! God Bless!
Lauralyn
First off, your use of humor throughout this post is spot on! I’m not
sure I’d be able to see things as graciously as you do if the roles were
reversed and Nathan looked to be on the losing side. Kudos to you on
that!
Yes, I’d have to say Team Nathan was jumping up and down (or in my case was a sappy puddle on the floor when he said “you matter to me”), but we’re still nervous that the writers could pull a switcheroo on us and put her with Lucas. I’m trying to mentally prepare myself just in case that happens. Personally, I just want this thing resolved. Please, writers, give us resolution to this triangle!
Lee’s storyline was excellent. I loved it! Suddenly there’s so much more depth to his character. His life seemed charmed, but now we see that’s not truly the case. He’s experienced deep hurt, and I’m so glad they’re fleshing out his character. Kavan Smith is excellent at humor, but wow was he spectacular with his emotion in this one! That was incredible. I was tearing up all over the place when he was on screen.
As far as Gowen goes, I don’t think he burned anything. I believe he gave Lucas the books, and as he said there were 19 more in his office. Goodness, I was tearing up during the scene with Gowen and Elizabeth too! So much emotion! And the look on his face after Lucas said something about him seeing reason, and Henry saying “Is that what I’ve done?” was telling. He looked haggard, and I think this is going to put a strain between him and Lucas. Hopefully not for long, because Lucas was in the right here, but I wonder how bad things are. I’m guessing Lucas will help fix it and hopefully he and Henry will be on good terms again, but I don’t know how it’s going to play out!
You know, until you mentioned it I hadn’t really thought that Fiona’s boss might be a bad man, but that makes a lot of sense in hindsight! Her reaction was too strong for it to be a simple transfer. Part of me wonders if Lucas will save the day for her, since he has San Francisco connections. Maybe he is her hero, and something will spark between them if the writers put Nathan with Elizabeth. Then they both stay in Hope Valley and are happy. As for the people saying Nathan and Fiona would be good together...no. Just...no. Even if Lucas and Elizabeth end up together, Nathan and Fiona are so incompatible. That pairing would be a real head-scratcher in my mind.
Ahhhh, Nathan and Elizabeth. *Sigh* Like I said, that end scene had me melted on the floor. IT’S ABOUT TIME!!! Lol. I was so glad he finally used his words and told her how he felt. And he apologized! I thought that scene was very well done. Though I’m left wondering what else he might have said, because it looked to me like he was about to say something more before he said “goodnight” and left.
Yes, I’d have to say Team Nathan was jumping up and down (or in my case was a sappy puddle on the floor when he said “you matter to me”), but we’re still nervous that the writers could pull a switcheroo on us and put her with Lucas. I’m trying to mentally prepare myself just in case that happens. Personally, I just want this thing resolved. Please, writers, give us resolution to this triangle!
Lee’s storyline was excellent. I loved it! Suddenly there’s so much more depth to his character. His life seemed charmed, but now we see that’s not truly the case. He’s experienced deep hurt, and I’m so glad they’re fleshing out his character. Kavan Smith is excellent at humor, but wow was he spectacular with his emotion in this one! That was incredible. I was tearing up all over the place when he was on screen.
As far as Gowen goes, I don’t think he burned anything. I believe he gave Lucas the books, and as he said there were 19 more in his office. Goodness, I was tearing up during the scene with Gowen and Elizabeth too! So much emotion! And the look on his face after Lucas said something about him seeing reason, and Henry saying “Is that what I’ve done?” was telling. He looked haggard, and I think this is going to put a strain between him and Lucas. Hopefully not for long, because Lucas was in the right here, but I wonder how bad things are. I’m guessing Lucas will help fix it and hopefully he and Henry will be on good terms again, but I don’t know how it’s going to play out!
You know, until you mentioned it I hadn’t really thought that Fiona’s boss might be a bad man, but that makes a lot of sense in hindsight! Her reaction was too strong for it to be a simple transfer. Part of me wonders if Lucas will save the day for her, since he has San Francisco connections. Maybe he is her hero, and something will spark between them if the writers put Nathan with Elizabeth. Then they both stay in Hope Valley and are happy. As for the people saying Nathan and Fiona would be good together...no. Just...no. Even if Lucas and Elizabeth end up together, Nathan and Fiona are so incompatible. That pairing would be a real head-scratcher in my mind.
Ahhhh, Nathan and Elizabeth. *Sigh* Like I said, that end scene had me melted on the floor. IT’S ABOUT TIME!!! Lol. I was so glad he finally used his words and told her how he felt. And he apologized! I thought that scene was very well done. Though I’m left wondering what else he might have said, because it looked to me like he was about to say something more before he said “goodnight” and left.
Now, I know you might disagree with me on this, but hear me out. I don’t think Elizabeth is leading both men on. If she ends up with Lucas, then yes, I think she’s led Nathan on big-time, especially since she’s basically asking him to ask her out when she’s in his office. She could have easily told him she wanted to be friends and let him down gently, but she’s not. On the other hand, when Lucas asked her out, she straight-up told him if he saw it as a date, she wasn’t going. He accepted that, but then he proceeded to make it very date-like. She was clear with him that she saw it as a friendship situation, and she’s never fished for him to ask her out (not that she would need to - he would jump at the opportunity if she even gave him the tiniest encouragement). With Lucas, as far as Elizabeth goes, she seems to see him as a friend. I kind of scratch my head when she claims to be torn, because I don’t see the torn. I see a woman who doesn’t want to hurt either man, but I have yet to see her acting as if she has any feelings for Lucas. The one exception might be that moment in the library when she got flustered by their nearness and fumbled for the door handle. So, in short, if she picks Nathan I don’t think she’s led Lucas on, but if she picks Lucas I think she has led Nathan on. Feel free to let me know your counter-thoughts on this, cuz as we know I am sooo biased! :)
Oh, I totally started singing the “shot to the heart” line when you mentioned that! Lol! Haha, and when Lee told Jesse to let it go, I started singing “Let it go, let it gooooooo!” in my head too! :D
Bill is such a sweetie. I love that he encourages Nathan, and that Nathan got it! I disagree about Nathan having a temper (which I believe we’ve talked about?), but he can definitely be moody and holy cow is he clueless when it comes to women! But I agree it makes him endearing (hehe, yes you said that out loud! :D) And hey, if you decide you like Nathan and Elizabeth together (down the line, of course, that’s probably waaaaay too much to ask right now :D), Team N will welcome you with open arms! Just sayin’! ;) But I totally understand you liking Lucas so much because you like Chris McNally. I’m the same way with liking Nathan so much because he’s played by Kevin McGarry. I love Chris too, and he’d better stay on the show if Nathan wins Elizabeth’s heart, because I don’t want to see Lucas leave! I like him a lot and want to see his story develop too.
Yeah, you’re right, Team Nathan thinks there have been tons of romantic moments between Nathan and Elizabeth, just quieter ones. Think Love Comes Softly rather than fireworks. Though to be honest though I think the fireworks are coming. Once Nathan’s shyness melts away and he can be as confident pursuing Elizabeth as he is when he’s on the job - look out!
Oh, Lucas. Good intentions, wrong actions. But I do like that even though he made a mistake, it’s going to help Elizabeth. I’m so glad she accepted the offer to send her chapters to the publisher! And I loved Lucas’ reaction….so cute! I loved seeing him so animated, haha. It was adorable.
And finally, that mysterious woman...I get the feeling that she’s connected to the baddie. She told Fiona she was going to catch the next train out and wanted something to eat first, and then she came back into the station and saw the arrest. Then all of a sudden she shows up in Hope Valley, and looks up sharply when Lucas calls Bill “judge.” She’s got to be connected to the bad guy. I don’t know, but it’ll be interesting to see if she’s in the episode next week!
Great review, as usual. Your writing is so good, and I was laughing throughout it this time. Thanks for taking the time to do these reviews. God bless!
Also, completely random, but with your opening line, the song "White Flag" by Chris Tomlin started playing in my head :)
My Reply
Lol! Yes! Good one with the "White Flag" connection and "Let It Go!" :D Well, a lot of this has already been answered by the finale episode, and I'll put most of my thoughts in the review tomorrow. However, after seeing this last episode I think we may have to agree to disagree about Elizabeth leading both guys on. I totally understand about her leading Nathan on as she's literally begging, if not daring him to ask her out. As for Lucas, while she has never fished for a date with him, she has never turned him down, and after that date/not date...He clearly pretty confident. She even told him that she thought what he did was sweet, and didn't seem to mind that things were "date like" during either outing. In fact she seemed to enjoy it. And since she's accepting of his actions that can lead to him thinking that she maybe likes him and that he's got a shot. I understand that Lucas is the one making the moves, but Elizabeth should be able to see through his actions, and put a stop to it if she doesn't have any feelings for him. Feel free to contradict any of this, as this is all just my opinion!
And yes, I'm sure you loved that Nathan scene! I'll admit that that was romantic. And thank you for the warm invitation, but it's a bit too early for that...Lol! I do have to be honest and say that Nathan has been winning me over more and more. I like him, and I have felt chemistry between him and Elizabeth, but...(Yep! You know!) I just can't help but feel disappointed every time it looks like Lucas isn't going to win. There are things that aren't perfect about him. I wish he was more down to earth, and had some casual attire, but I still can see him and Elizabeth being a cute couple who are each other's best friends. Like I said in another reply I kind of think Lucas could take an Elizabeth journey. Elizabeth first came to HV as the Hamilton girl she was, and slowly over the course of this show became the frontier woman she is now. Lucas could do that too. Slowly loosen up, and become more down to earth. Just my thoughts! Feel free to let me know yours! (Or if I was too Lucas-focused for you! Lol!)
And thank you so much for the encouragement! I'm so happy you were able to have a good laugh at the review! Take care and God Bless!
My Reply
Lol! Yes! Good one with the "White Flag" connection and "Let It Go!" :D Well, a lot of this has already been answered by the finale episode, and I'll put most of my thoughts in the review tomorrow. However, after seeing this last episode I think we may have to agree to disagree about Elizabeth leading both guys on. I totally understand about her leading Nathan on as she's literally begging, if not daring him to ask her out. As for Lucas, while she has never fished for a date with him, she has never turned him down, and after that date/not date...He clearly pretty confident. She even told him that she thought what he did was sweet, and didn't seem to mind that things were "date like" during either outing. In fact she seemed to enjoy it. And since she's accepting of his actions that can lead to him thinking that she maybe likes him and that he's got a shot. I understand that Lucas is the one making the moves, but Elizabeth should be able to see through his actions, and put a stop to it if she doesn't have any feelings for him. Feel free to contradict any of this, as this is all just my opinion!
And yes, I'm sure you loved that Nathan scene! I'll admit that that was romantic. And thank you for the warm invitation, but it's a bit too early for that...Lol! I do have to be honest and say that Nathan has been winning me over more and more. I like him, and I have felt chemistry between him and Elizabeth, but...(Yep! You know!) I just can't help but feel disappointed every time it looks like Lucas isn't going to win. There are things that aren't perfect about him. I wish he was more down to earth, and had some casual attire, but I still can see him and Elizabeth being a cute couple who are each other's best friends. Like I said in another reply I kind of think Lucas could take an Elizabeth journey. Elizabeth first came to HV as the Hamilton girl she was, and slowly over the course of this show became the frontier woman she is now. Lucas could do that too. Slowly loosen up, and become more down to earth. Just my thoughts! Feel free to let me know yours! (Or if I was too Lucas-focused for you! Lol!)
And thank you so much for the encouragement! I'm so happy you were able to have a good laugh at the review! Take care and God Bless!
Kelley's Girl
I wanted also to say, keep working on that novel girl! I have a
completed one on my mac, just waiting for me to figure out what to do
with it. Good plot, just needs some editing. :)
My Reply
Aww! Thanks! It's like I have so much done for it, and yet still have so much to do! Lol! But you have my total congrats on your FINISHED novel! Way to go, girl! Kudos for doing one of the hardest things about writing a novel...finishing it! (Or at least that's my problem! Lol!) You keep working at yours too! Don't let it stay stuck on your Mac! Lol! Hopefully God sees fit that you'll be published one day! Thank you, and God Bless!
Kelley's Girl
I would love to comment further, but I have searched for and seen every
preview and sneak peek available! I have some thoughts, but, alas, they
would be spoilers, so I just won't go there.
Thanks again for the blog, I always love reading your point of view and can't wait to see what happens Sunday night! I will comment on your next blog after the finale. :)
Thanks again for the blog, I always love reading your point of view and can't wait to see what happens Sunday night! I will comment on your next blog after the finale. :)
My Reply
Thanks for not spoiling anything for me! I appreciate it, although I usually end up spoiling something for myself through social media. Lol! And thank you! I enjoy reading your point of view too! God Bless!
Lauralyn
Oh, I so hope there's a season 8 announcement either right before or right after the finale! ESPECIALLY if there's a cliffhanger!
You know what else I'm hoping for? Resolution! Despite the fact that a lot of people think there won't be, I'm holding out hope. Mostly because I can't stomach the idea of a whole off-season of both teams speculating and holding out hope for something that might not happen. We just need to know Elizabeth's choice and then everyone can make their peace about it and get ready for the new season, should it be renewed.
I get the feeling everything you think will happen is going to happen (hopefully except that last one where she picks no one). Those are all very plausible. Two more days until we find out! (Deep breaths, deep breaths).
Oh! I forgot to mention something I would like to see happen - even
though I highly doubt it will. Faith comes back for a visit! I miss her
and Carson together.
My Reply
Well, one out of two is better than nothing right? Lol! Actually it could be two out of two, but....we'll have to wait to find out. Again. (Oh, my poor heart!) I so agree with you! I don't want to hope for something that I may never get, and unless Elizabeth makes a decision in a Christmas Special, (Should we have one) it could feel like a betrayal if Lucas started to fall for another girl before Elizabeth picks, if not played off right. But all I can do is wait....again....(Sigh.) God Bless!
Thank you again for all the comments! I enjoy reading them! Feel free to comment below and I will try and get back to you next week! Stay safe, and God Bless!
Comments
Post a Comment